It's cricket, but not as we know it, Jim...
Yesterday marked the end of the inaugural IPL 20/20 series in India. I watched the game and it was exciting after it's own fashion, which I'm sure pleased the organisers who would have been dreading another one-sided fizzle out to the competition. The cricket was ugly, but this is something that now comes with the territory. Matches are regularly decided by "unrecognised batsmen" fluking the ball to fine leg.
I don't really mind watching it but I hope it doesn't deal the much-hyped death blow to test cricket. That is a completely different game altogether. People unfamiliar with cricket often don't understand the sport because they don't grasp, or haven't been told that the five day game is a strategic effort, depending on many factors other than just trying to cream the ball over the boundary ropes. It involves strange notions such as survival. It requires a strength of captaincy not part of the shorter game, where rather simpler tactics rule.
Its instructive that this is happening, and being driven by the sub-continent where love of spectacle and firecrackers seems to outweigh any desire for content and substance. Cricket has come to Bollywood. This sounds elitist, but I don't intend it to be. I just don't want Test cricket to suffer - I hope there is room for both.
As an indication of what we might lose, think of the great writing that has been inspired by test match cricket. The journalism and commentary of John Arlott and Neville Cardus for example. I cannot imagine the short game inspiring anything like that. What is there to talk about other than who hit the longest six? You cannot ponder about the decisions made on the basis that the pitch might take spin on the fifth morning. Or rejoice in the heroics of Atherton batting for 2 weeks to save the Johannesburg Test.
Maybe people got tired of the dominance of Australia recently (the introduction of the 3 day test match!) but there are signs that this is coming to an end. In the Carribean at the moment there are even some signs that the West Indies are starting to become a cricketing unit once more. I hope so - we need them
Here's a quote from John Arlott, (paraphrased) that sums it up for me. (Oval test W Indies v England, 1963)
"Lock runs in and bowls at the end of a long spell. Sobers hits the ball in the direction of the Houses of Parliament, but it doesn't go that far, and they run two. The umpire takes of the bails and that'll be tea on day three"



